Pipe Down! That Noise Might Affect Your Plants

Mar 25, 2012
Originally published on March 26, 2012 7:59 am

Researchers haven't given much thought to the effect of noise and noise pollution on plants. After all, plants don't have ears — at least, not the kind you hear with — so there doesn't seem to be much point. But thanks to ecologist Clinton Francis, that could be about to change.

Francis is a postdoctoral researcher at the National Evolutionary Synthesis Center in North Carolina. But he has spent the past few years in northwestern New Mexico, studying noise pollution in Rattlesnake Canyon.

Gnarled juniper trees and pinon pines dominate the canyon's landscape of high mesas and rough sandstone cliffs. Tucked in among the trees are thousands of natural gas wells, about a third of them pressurized by ear-splitting compressors.

"They run 24 hours a day, 365 days a year, with the exception of periodic maintenance," Francis says, "so they are going all the time."

Since 2005, he has been studying how Rattlesnake Canyon's birds respond to the compressors' nonstop racket. And it looks like the noise is having an effect.

"Black-chinned hummingbirds, for example, tend to prefer and settle in really noisy landscapes, and Western scrub jays tend to avoid these noisy areas," he says.

If the noise is changing the way the birds behave, Francis wondered, it might have an effect on plants in the area, too. Take, for example, the relationship between pinon trees and scrub jays.

"We know that jays are really important seed dispersers for pinon pine," Francis says. The jays bury the seeds to snack on later, but inevitably, some get forgotten and grow into new pine trees.

Francis already knew there were fewer pine seedlings at noisy sites. Was that because the noise was keeping the jays away from their pine nuts?

To find out, Francis set up motion-trigger cameras at both noisy and quiet sites, put out some seeds and waited.

As he predicted, the jays were only stashing nuts at quiet sites, not at noisy ones. But in a twist, the seeds at noisy sites were being gobbled up anyway – by mice. And the mice weren't leaving any seeds behind to sprout.

It looked like the compressor noise was hitting the pine trees with a double whammy. "We're just not getting as many seeds going into the seed bank in noisy areas, and the ones that do might be consumed by the mice," Francis says.

But he also says the effect of noise on the canyon's plants isn't all bad. A flower pollinated by hummingbirds did better near the compressors. Remember, hummingbirds seem to like the noise — probably, Francis says, because it drives away the scrub jays that would otherwise eat the hummingbirds' eggs and young.

Francis just published his research in the British journal Proceedings of the Royal Society B. And other researchers are already taking note.

Ecologist Gail Patricelli, of the University of California, also studies how gas-drilling noise affects birds — in her case, the greater sage grouse. She says as far as she knows, Francis' work is the first to show how noise affects plants.

"You kind of hit yourself on the forehead and think, why didn't I think of that?" Patricelli says. And even at her remote field site in Wyoming, she says, it's not quiet.

"We hear airplanes, we hear roads going, you know, way off in the distance that are too far away to see, and yet you can still hear them, because sound travels much, much further than a lot of the other types of disturbance," Patricelli says. "And so it's just an enormous land area that's impacted by noise, and we know remarkably little about what that noise does to the ecosystem."

But it seems likely that for long-lived species like the pinon pines in Rattlesnake Canyon, the effects of noise may continue to reverberate long after the compressors have gone silent.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

DAVID GREENE, HOST:

Plants don't have ears, right? And if they can't hear you would assume that noise wouldn't matter much to them, which is why researchers haven't given much thought to the idea that noise might affect plants. But as Veronique LaCapra of St. Louis Public Radio reports, all of that may be about to change.

VERONIQUE LACAPRA, BYLINE: In northwestern New Mexico's Rattlesnake Canyon, gnarled juniper trees and pinyon pines dominate a landscape of high mesas and rough sandstone cliffs. Tucked in among the trees are thousands of natural gas wells, about a third of them pressurized by ear-splitting compressors.

(SOUNDBITE OF COMPRESSOR)

CLINTON FRANCIS: They run 24 hours a day, 365 days a year, with the exception of periodic maintenance, so they are going all the time.

LACAPRA: That's Clinton Francis of at the National Evolutionary Synthesis Center in North Carolina. Since 2005, he's been studying how Rattlesnake Canyon's birds respond to the compressors' nonstop racket.

FRANCIS: Black-chinned hummingbirds, for example, tend to prefer and settle in really noisy landscapes, and Western scrub jays tend to avoid these noisy areas.

LACAPRA: If the noise in the canyon is changing the way the birds behave. And that got Francis wondering. Maybe it's having an effect on plants, too. Take pinyon trees and scrub jays.

FRANCIS: We know that jays are really important seed dispersers for pinyon pine.

LACAPRA: The jays bury the seeds to snack on later, but inevitably, some get forgotten and grow into new pine trees. Francis already knew there were fewer pine seedlings at noisy sites. Was that because the noise was keeping the jays away from their pine nuts?

(SOUNDBITE OF BIRD TWEETING)

LACAPRA: Francis set up motion-trigger cameras at both noisy and quiet sites, put out some pine seeds and waited. As he predicted, the jays were only stashing nuts at noisy sites.

FRANCIS: We only found them removing seeds on the quiet sites.

LACAPRA: But there was a twist. At the noisy sites, mice were gobbling up the seeds, not leaving any behind to sprout. So for the pine trees it looked the compressor noise was delivering a double whammy.

FRANCIS: We're just not getting as many seeds going into the seed bank in noisy areas, and the ones that do might be consumed by the mice that are there.

LACAPRA: But, Francis says, the effect of noise on the canyon's plants wasn't all bad. A flower pollinated by hummingbirds did better near the compressors. Remember, hummingbirds seem to like the noise - probably, Francis says, because it drives away the scrub jays that would otherwise eat the hummingbirds' eggs and young.

Francis just published his research in the British journal called Proceedings of the Royal Society B.

University of California Davis ecologist Gail Patricelli, also studies how gas-drilling noise affects birds - in her case, the greater sage grouse. She says as far as she knows, Francis's work is the first to show how noise affects plants.

GAIL PATRICELLI: You kind of hit yourself on the forehead and think, why didn't I think of that?

LACAPRA: I reached Patricelli on her cell phone at a remote field site in Wyoming. She says even there it's not quiet.

PATRICELLI: We hear airplanes. We hear roads going, you know, way off in the distance that are too far away to see and yet you can still hear them, because sound travels much, much further than a lot of the other types of disturbance. And so it's just an enormous land area that's impacted by noise, and we know remarkably little about what that noise does to the ecosystem.

LACAPRA: But it seems likely that for long-lived species like the pinyon pines in Rattlesnake Canyon, the effects of noise may continue to reverberate long after the sound of the compressors has gone silent.

For NPR News, I'm Veronique LaCapra.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

GREENE: Plants, if you're listening, this is NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.